Thumbs Summary 2007

2006	2008
Where are the latest reviews?

BOTH THUMBS UP	EBERT	ROEPER	MOVIE TITLE	SHOW DATE
(sorted by)
	(Phillips)		American Gangster (see key)	10/28/2007
	(Schwarzbaum)		The Astronaut Farmer	02/11/2007
	(Silberling)		Away From Her* (see key)	05/13/2007
	(Scott)		Bee Movie	11/04/2007
	(Phillips)		Before The Devil Knows You're Dead	10/28/2007
	(Morgan)		Beyond The Gates	03/11/2007
	(Smith)		Black Snake Moan	02/18/2007
	(Smith)		Breach	02/18/2007
	(Smith)		Bridge To Terabithia	02/18/2007
	(Karger)		Broken English	07/15/2007
	(Phillips)		The Bourne Ultimatum	07/29/2007
	(Murty)		Catch And Release	01/21/2007
	(Silberling)		Civic Duty	05/13/2007
	(Phillips)		Control	10/28/2007
	(Edelstein)		Crazy Love	06/03/2007
	(Phillips)		Dan In Real Life	10/28/2007
	(Scott)		Darfur Now	11/12/2007
	(Hunter)		Delirious	08/19/2007
	(Lemire)		Diggers	04/29/2007
	(Scott)		Disturbia	04/15/2007
	(Scott)		The Diving Bell And The Butterfly	12/02/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Eastern Promises	09/09/2007
	(Phillips)		Enchanted	11/18/2007
	(Wilonsky)		1408	06/17/2007
	(Scott)		The Golden Compass	12/09/2007
	(Edelstein)		Gracie	06/03/2007
	(Phillips)		The Great Debaters	12/23/2007
	(Lemire)		Grindhouse* (see key)	04/01/2007
	(Karger)		Hairspray	07/15/2007
	(Karger)		Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix	07/15/2007
	(Scott)		The Hoax* (see key)	04/08/2007
	(Morgan)		The Host	03/11/2007
	(Scott)		Hot Fuzz* (see key)	04/15/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Hunting Party	09/02/2007
	(Edelstein)		L'Iceberg	05/27/2007
	(Phillips)		I Am Legend	12/16/2007
	(Phillips)		I'm Not There (see key)	11/25/2007
	(Mellencamp)		In The Land Of Women	04/22/2007
	(Wilonsky)		In The Shadow Of The Moon	09/09/2007
	(Morgan)		I Think I Love My Wife	03/11/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Into The Wild (see key)	09/23/2007
	(Phillips)		I Want Someone To Eat Cheese With	10/21/2007
	(Scott)		Juno (see key)	12/02/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The King Of Kong	08/26/2007
	(Edelstein)		Knocked Up* (see key)	05/27/2007
	(Tulich)		Live Free Or Die Hard	07/01/2007
	(Smith)		The Lives Of Others* (see key)	02/18/2007
	(Edelstein)		The Lookout* (see key)	03/18/2007
	(Edelstein)		Maxed Out	03/18/2007
	(Lemire)		Meet the Robinsons	04/01/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Michael Clayton (see key)	10/07/2007
	(Wilonsky)		A Mighty Heart	06/17/2007
	(Scott)		Miss Potter	01/07/2007
	(Phillips)		The Mist	11/25/2007
	(Karger)		My Best Friend	07/15/2007
	(Wilonsky)		My Kid Could Paint That	10/14/2007
	(Scott)		No Country For Old Men (see key)	11/04/2007
	(Phillips)		No End In Sight	07/29/2007
	(Wilonsky)		No Reservations	07/22/2007
	(Scott)		Notes On A Scandal	01/07/2007
	(Pennacchio)		The Number 23 (see key)	02/25/2007
	(Edelstein)		Ocean's Thirteen (see key)	06/03/2007
	(Phillips)		Once* (see key)	05/20/2007
	(Scott)		The Painted Veil	01/07/2007
	(Scott)		Pan's Labyrinth	01/07/2007
	(Edelstein)		Paris Je T'aime (see key)	06/03/2007
	(Morris)		Pride	03/25/2007
	(Tulich)		Ratatouille (see key)	07/01/2007
	(Scott)		The Savages (see key)	12/02/2007
	(Murty)		Seraphim Falls	01/21/2007
	(Phillips)		SiCKO	06/24/2007
	(Phillips)		The Simpsons Movie	07/29/2007
	(Karger)		Stardust	08/12/2007
	(Scott)		Starting Out In The Evening	12/02/2007
	(Phillips)		Superbad (see key)	08/05/2007
	(Edelstein)		Surf's Up	06/03/2007
	(Phillips)		Sweeney Todd (see key)	12/16/2007
	(Karger)		Talk To Me	07/15/2007
	(Phillips)		Things We Lost In The Fire	10/21/2007
	(Phillips)		This Christmas	11/25/2007
	(Morgan)		300* (see key)	03/11/2007
	(Wilonsky)		3:10 To Yuma	09/02/2007
	(Lemire)		Waitress	04/29/2007
	(Scott)		Walk Hard	12/09/2007
	(Edelstein)		The Wind That Shakes The Barley	03/18/2007
	(Scott)		Wristcutters: A Love Story	11/04/2007
	(Phillips)		You Kill Me	06/24/2007
	(Phillips)		Zodiac* (see key)	03/04/2007
	(Pennacchio)		Amazing Grace	02/25/2007
	(Hunter)		Arctic Tale	08/19/2007
	(Murty)		Arthur And The Invisibles	01/21/2007
	(Karger)		Becoming Jane	08/12/2007
	(Edelstein)		Bug	05/27/2007
	(Hunter)		Death At A Funeral	08/19/2007
	(Wilonsky)		December Boys	10/07/2007
	(Tulich)		Eagle Vs. Shark	07/01/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Elizabeth: The Golden Age	10/14/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Fantastic 4: Rise Of The Silver Surfer	06/17/2007
	(Scott)		Firehouse Dog	04/08/2007
	(Scott)		4 Months, 3 Weeks And 2 Days (see key)	12/30/2007
	(Mellencamp)		Fracture	04/22/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Game Plan	09/30/2007
	(Silberling)		Georgia Rule# (see key)	05/13/2007
	(Phillips)		Hot Rod	08/05/2007
			I Know Who Killed Me (see key)	01/13/2008
	(Hunter)		The Invasion	08/19/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Lars And The Real Girl (see key)	10/14/2007
	(Morris)		The Last Mimzy	03/25/2007
			License To Wed (see key)	01/13/2008
	(Mellencamp)		Lonely Hearts	04/22/2007
	(Phillips)		Margot At The Wedding	11/18/2007
	(Phillips)		Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium	11/18/2007
	(Karger)		Rocket Science	08/12/2007
	(Edelstein)		Severance	05/27/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Shoot 'Em Up (see key)	09/09/2007
	(Morris)		Shooter	03/25/2007
	(Phillips)		Smarter For 10	03/04/2007
	(Scott)		Terror's Advocate (see key)	12/30/2007
	(Scott)		There Will Be Blood (see key)	12/30/2007
	(Scott)		12:08 East Of Bucharest (see key)	12/30/2007
	(Mellencamp)		Vacancy	04/22/2007
	(Wilonsky)		We Own The Night	10/14/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Across The Universe	09/16/2007
	(Murty)		Alpha Dog	01/21/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Assassination Of Jesse James	09/23/2007
	(Scott)		Atonement	12/09/2007
	(Phillips)		Beowulf	11/18/2007
	(Lemire)		Blades Of Glory	04/01/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Brave One	09/16/2007
	(Phillips)		El Cantante	08/05/2007
	(Phillips)		Cashback	07/29/2007
	(Phillips)		Charlie Wilson's War	12/23/2007
	(Scott)		Curse Of The Golden Flower	01/07/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Darjeeling Limited	09/30/2007
	(Hunter)		The 11th Hour	08/19/2007
	(Schwarzbaum)		Factory Girl	02/11/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Feast Of Love	09/30/2007
			First Snow	04/08/2007
	(Scott)		Fred Claus	11/12/2007
	(Phillips)		Gone Baby Gone (see key)	10/21/2007
	(Scott)		Grace Is Gone	12/09/2007
	(Phillips)		Hostel: Part II (see key)	01/13/2008
	(Wilonsky)		The Hottest State	09/16/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Interview	07/22/2007
	(Wilonsky)		In The Valley Of Elah	09/16/2007
	(Phillips)		Introducing The Dwights	07/29/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Jane Austen Book Club	10/07/2007
	(Scott)		Jimmy Carter Man From Plains	11/04/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Kingdom	09/30/2007
	(Phillips)		The Kite Runner	12/16/2007
	(Scott)		Lions For Lambs	11/12/2007
	(Phillips)		Love In The Time Of Cholera	11/18/2007
	(Lemire)		Lucky You	05/06/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Lust, Caution	09/30/2007
	(Edelstein)		Mr. Brooks	06/03/2007
	(Smith)		Music & Lyrics	02/18/2007
	(Morgan)		The Namesake	03/11/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Nancy Drew	06/17/2007
	(Edelstein)		Pirates Of The Caribbean: At World's End	05/27/2007
	(Phillips)		P.S. I Love You	12/23/2007
	(Phillips)		Purple Violets	11/25/2007
	(Pennacchio)		Reno 911!: Miami	02/25/2007
	(Phillips)		Rescue Dawn	06/24/2007
	(Schwarzbaum)		The Situation	02/11/2007
	(Lemire)		Snow Cake	04/29/2007
	(Phillips)		The Ten	08/05/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Trade	09/30/2007
	(Karger)		Transformers	07/15/2007
	(Silberling)		28 Weeks Later	05/13/2007
	(Karger)		2 Days In Paris	08/12/2007
	(Scott)		Year Of The Dog	04/15/2007
	(Phillips)		Youth Without Youth	12/16/2007
	(Murty)		Alone With Her	01/21/2007
	(Phillips)		Alvin And The Chipmunks	12/16/2007
	(Scott)		The Amateurs	12/09/2007
	(Scott)		Aqua Teen Hunger Force	04/15/2007
	(Scott)		Are We Done Yet?	04/08/2007
	(Phillips)		August Rush	11/25/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Balls Of Fury	09/02/2007
	(Schwarzbaum)		Because I Said So (see key)	02/11/2007
	(Phillips)		Black Sheep	06/24/2007
	(Phillips)		Bratz (see key)	08/05/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Brothers Solomon	09/09/2007
	(Lemire)		The Condemned	04/29/2007
	(Karger)		Daddy Day Camp	08/12/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Death Sentence	09/02/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Dedication	09/02/2007
	(Phillips)		Evan Almighty	06/24/2007
	(Tulich)		Evening	07/01/2007
	(Phillips)		Even Money	05/20/2007
	(Silberling)		The Ex	05/13/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Fido	06/17/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Fierce People	09/09/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Good Luck Chuck (see key)	09/23/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Goya's Ghosts	07/22/2007
	(Phillips)		Gray Matters	03/04/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Heartbreak Kid (see key)	10/07/2007
	(Scott)		Hitman	12/02/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Illegal Tender	08/26/2007
	(Wilonsky)		I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry (see key)	07/22/2007
	(Wilonsky)		King Of California	09/23/2007
	(Scott)		Martian Child	11/04/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Mr. Bean's Holiday	08/26/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Mr. Woodcock	09/16/2007
	(Phillips)		Music Within	10/28/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Nanny Diaries	08/26/2007
	(Phillips)		National Treasure: Book Of Secrets	12/23/2007
	(Schwarzbaum)		Norbit# (see key)	02/11/2007
	(Phillips)		Perfect Holiday	12/16/2007
	(Scott)		Perfect Stranger (see key)	04/15/2007
	(Scott)		Perfume: The Story Of A Murderer	01/07/2007
	(Edelstein)		Premonition	03/18/2007
	(Phillips)		Provoked	05/20/2007
	(Scott)		Rail & Ties	11/12/2007
	(Scott)		The Reaping (see key)	04/08/2007
	(Scott)		Redacted	12/02/2007
	(Morris)		Reign Over Me	03/25/2007
	(Phillips)		Rendition	10/21/2007
	(Phillips)		Reservation Road	10/21/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Resurrecting The Champ	08/26/2007
	(Karger)		Rush Hour 3 (see key)	08/12/2007
	(Wilonsky)		The Seeker: The Dark Is Rising	10/07/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Self Medicated	09/02/2007
	(Phillips)		Shrek The Third	05/20/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Sleuth	10/14/2007
	(Phillips)		Southland Tales (see key)	11/18/2007
	(Lemire)		Spider-Man 3	05/06/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Sunshine	07/22/2007
	(Wilonsky)		Sydney White	09/23/2007
	(Phillips)		30 Days Of Night	10/21/2007
	(Morris)		TMNT	03/25/2007
	(Edelstein)		The Ultimate Gift	03/18/2007
	(Phillips)		The Wendell Baker Story	05/20/2007
	(Lemire)		What Love Is	04/01/2007
	(Phillips)		Wild Hogs (see key)	03/04/2007

 

bold = best of the year (12/30/2007 Roeper & Scott)

italic = worst of the year (01/13/2008 Roeper & Phillips)

* = best of the year so far (06/10/2007 Roeper & Lemire)

# = worst of the year so far (06/10/2007 Roeper & Lemire)

 

complete listing of Ebert, Siskel, & Roeper's annual top ten lists