Ebert & Roeper Thumbs Summary
2005-2008
arrow 2008  
Where are the latest reviews?
BOTH
THUMBS
UP
EBERT ROEPER MOVIE
TITLE
SHOW
DATE
      (sorted by)  
A
  thumbs up
(Ridley)
thumbs down
 
Accepted 08/20/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Across The Universe 09/16/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down The Adventures Of Shark Boy And Lava Girl In 3-D 06/12/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Akeelah And The Bee* (see key) 04/30/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Alex Rider: Operation Stormbreaker 10/15/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Aliens Of The Deep 01/30/2005
  thumbs up
(Willard)
thumbs down
 
All The King's Men (see key) 09/24/2006
  thumbs down
(Murty)
thumbs down
 
Alone With Her 01/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Alpha Dog 01/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Alvin And The Chipmunks 12/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Amateurs 12/09/2007
  thumbs up
(Pennacchio)
thumbs down
 
Amazing Grace 02/25/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down American Dreamz 04/23/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up American Gun 03/26/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
American Gangster (see key) 10/28/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down An American Haunting 05/07/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
American Teen 07/27/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
Apocalypto 12/10/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Aquamarine 03/05/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Aqua Teen Hunger Force 04/15/2007
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
Arctic Tale 08/19/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Are We Done Yet? 04/08/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Are We There Yet? 01/23/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up The Aristocrats 07/31/2005
  thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs down
 
Arthur And The Invisibles 01/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Art School Confidential 04/30/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Ask The Dust 03/12/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Assassination Of Jesse James 09/23/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Assault On Precinct 13 01/23/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
The Astronaut Farmer 02/11/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down ATL 04/02/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Atonement 12/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
August Rush 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
Away From Her* (see key) 05/13/2007
 
B
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Babel (see key) 10/29/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Baby Mama 04/27/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Bad News Bears 07/17/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Baghead 06/15/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down The Ballad Of Jack And Rose 04/03/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Balls Of Fury 09/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Bank Job* (see key) 03/02/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Basic Instinct 2# (see key) 04/02/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Batman Begins 06/05/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down The Baxter 08/28/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down Beauty Shop 04/03/2005
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs down
 
Because I Said So (see key) 02/11/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Because Of Winn-Dixie 02/20/2005
  thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Becoming Jane 08/12/2007
  thumbs down thumbs up Be Cool 03/06/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Bee Movie 11/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Senecal)
thumbs down
 
Beerfest 08/27/2006
    thumbs up Beerleague 10/01/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Bee Season 11/13/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Before The Devil Knows You're Dead 10/28/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Be Kind Rewind 02/25/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Beowulf 11/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Best Of Youth 04/03/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Bewitched (see key) 06/26/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
Beyond The Gates 03/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Tyler)
thumbs down
 
The Black Dahlia 09/17/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Black Sheep 06/24/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Black Snake Moan 02/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Blades Of Glory 04/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Sagal)
thumbs up
 
Blood Diamond (see key) 12/03/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Bobby 11/19/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Van Peebles)
thumbs up
 
Borat 11/05/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Bordertown 02/17/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Born Into Brothels 02/20/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Bourne Ultimatum 07/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Boy A 07/27/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Bratz (see key) 08/05/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Brave One 09/16/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Breach 02/18/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Breakfast On Pluto 11/20/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
Breaking And Entering 12/17/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up The Break-up 06/04/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Brick 04/09/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Bride And Prejudice 01/30/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Brideshead Revisited 07/27/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Bridge To Terabithia 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Brokeback Mountain (see key) 12/04/2005
  thumbs down
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
Broken Bridges 09/10/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Broken English 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Broken Flowers 07/31/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Brothers 05/08/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up The Brothers Grimm 08/28/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Brothers Solomon 09/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Bubble* (see key) 01/22/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Bucket List 01/06/2008
  thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Bug 05/27/2007
 
C
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Candy 11/19/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
El Cantante 08/05/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Cape Of Good Hope 11/20/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Capote (see key) 10/02/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Cars* (see key) 06/11/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up Casanova 12/25/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Cashback 07/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Casino Royale 11/19/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Cassandra's Dream 01/20/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Catch A Fire 10/29/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Catch And Release 01/21/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Chaos Theory 04/13/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Chapter 27 03/30/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Charlie And The Chocolate Factory 07/10/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Charlie Bartlett 02/25/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Charlie Wilson's War 12/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
Charlotte's Web 12/10/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Cheaper By The Dozen 2 12/25/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Chicago 10 03/02/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Chicken Little 11/06/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Children Of Huang Shi 05/25/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Thompson)
thumbs up
 
Children Of Men 12/24/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up The Chorus 01/23/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Chronicles Of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch & The Wardrobe 12/04/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Chronicles Of Narnia: Prince Caspian 05/18/2008
  thumbs down thumbs up The Chumscrubber 08/07/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Cinderella Man 05/22/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
City Of Men 03/09/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
Civic Duty 05/13/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Clean 06/11/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Cleaner 05/25/2008
  thumbs down thumbs up Clerks II 07/23/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Click (see key) 06/25/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Cloverfield 01/20/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Coach Carter 01/09/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
College Road Trip 03/09/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Come Early Morning 11/19/2006
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
The Condemned 04/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Conspiracy 03/16/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Constant Gardener 08/28/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Constantine (see key) 02/20/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Control 10/28/2007
  thumbs down
(Ridley)
thumbs down
 
Conversations With Other Women 08/20/2006
  thumbs down
(Ramis)
thumbs down
 
Copying Beethoven 11/12/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Corpse Bride 09/25/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Crash (see key) 04/24/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Crazy Love 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Cronicas 07/31/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Crossover 09/03/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
CSNY/Deja Vu 08/03/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down Curious George 03/05/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Curse Of The Golden Flower 01/07/2007
 
D
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Daddy Day Camp 08/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Dan In Real Life 10/28/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Darfur Now 11/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Darjeeling Limited 09/30/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Dark Knight 07/13/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down Dark Water 07/10/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Dave Chappelle's Block Party 03/05/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Da Vinci Code (see key) 05/28/2006
  thumbs up
(Scott)
  Days Of Glory (see key) 12/31/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Thompson)
thumbs up
 
The Dead Girl 12/24/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Deal 04/27/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down The Deal 07/10/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Dear Frankie 03/06/2005
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
Death At A Funeral 08/19/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Death Of A President 10/29/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Death Sentence 09/02/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down D.E.B.S. (see key) 03/27/2005
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
December Boys 10/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Deception 04/27/2008
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Deck The Halls (see key) 11/26/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Dedication 09/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Definitely, Maybe 02/17/2008
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Déjà Vu 11/26/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs up
 
Delirious 08/19/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Deliver Us From Evil 10/15/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
The Departed (see key) 10/01/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up Derailed 11/13/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Deuce Bigalow: European Gigolo (see key) 08/14/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Devil And Daniel Johnston 04/02/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Devil's Rejects 07/24/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up The Devil Wears Prada 07/02/2006
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Diary Of The Dead 02/25/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Diggers 04/29/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Dirty 02/26/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Dirty Love (see key) 09/18/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Disturbia 04/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Diving Bell And The Butterfly 12/02/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Dominion: A Prequel To The Exorcist 05/22/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Domino 10/16/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Don't Come Knocking 03/19/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
  Doogal (see key) 01/14/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Doom (see key) 10/23/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Dot The I 03/20/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Down And Derby 04/17/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Downfall 03/13/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Down In The Valley 05/07/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Dreamer 10/23/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
Dreamgirls 12/10/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Drillbit Taylor 03/23/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Duane Hopwood 11/27/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Duck Season 03/19/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down The Dukes Of Hazzard (see key) 08/07/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Duma 07/31/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down The Dying Gaul 11/06/2005
 
E
  thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs down
 
Eagle Vs. Shark 07/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Eastern Promises 09/09/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Eight Below 02/19/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
88 Minutes 04/20/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Elegy 08/10/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Elektra (see key) 01/23/2005
  thumbs down
(Hunter)
thumbs up
 
The 11th Hour 08/19/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Elizabeth: The Golden Age 10/14/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Elizabethtown 10/16/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Ellie Parker 11/27/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Empire Falls 05/22/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Enchanted 11/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Encounters At The End Of The World 06/29/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down L'Enfant (The Child) (see key) 03/26/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Enron: The Smartest Guys In The Room 04/17/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Eros 04/10/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Evan Almighty 06/24/2007
  thumbs down
(Tulich)
thumbs down
 
Evening 07/01/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Even Money 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Tyler)
thumbs down
 
Everyone's Hero 09/17/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Everything Is Illuminated 09/18/2005
  thumbs down
(Silberling)
thumbs down
 
The Ex 05/13/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Exorcism Of Emily Rose 09/11/2005
 
F
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
Factory Girl 02/11/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Factotum 09/03/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Failure To Launch# (see key) 03/12/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Fall 05/11/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Family Stone 12/04/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Fantastic Four (see key) 07/10/2005
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fantastic 4: Rise Of The Silver Surfer 06/17/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down The Fast And The Furious:
Tokyo Drift
06/18/2006
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Fast Food Nation 11/19/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Feast Of Love 09/30/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Fever Pitch 04/03/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fido 06/17/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fierce People 09/09/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)
  51 Birch Street (see key) 12/31/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Final Destination 3 02/12/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Finding Amanda 06/29/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Finding Home 11/20/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Find Me Guilty 03/19/2006
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Firehouse Dog 04/08/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Firewall 02/12/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up First Descent 12/04/2005
    thumbs up First Snow 04/08/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Kit)
thumbs up
 
Flags Of Our Fathers (see key) 10/08/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Flawless 03/30/2008
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Flicka 10/22/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Flight Plan 09/25/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Flock 05/18/2008
  thumbs up
(Van Peebles)
thumbs down
 
Flushed Away 11/05/2006
  thumbs up
(Willard)
thumbs down
 
Flyboys (see key) 09/24/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Fly Me To The Moon 08/17/2008
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Fool's Gold 02/10/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Foot Fist Way 06/01/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Forbidden Kingdom 04/20/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Forgetting Sarah Marshall* (see key) 04/06/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Ramis)
thumbs up
 
For Your Consideration 11/12/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Fountain 11/26/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
1408 06/17/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The 40 Year Old Virgin (see key) 08/14/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Four Brothers 08/14/2005
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
4 Months, 3 Weeks And 2 Days (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Fracture 04/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Fred Claus 11/12/2007
  thumbs down thumbs up Freedomland 02/19/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up Friends With Money 04/09/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Frozen River 08/03/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Funny Games 03/16/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Fun With Dick And Jane 12/25/2005
  thumbs down
(Ramis)
thumbs down
 
Fur (see key) 11/12/2006
 
G
  thumbs down thumbs up G 10/30/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down The Game Of Their Lives 04/24/2005
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Game Plan 09/30/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Game 6* (see key) 03/12/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Garfield: A Tail Of Two Kitties 06/18/2006
  thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs down
 
Georgia Rule (see key) 05/13/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Get Rich Or Die Tryin' 11/06/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Get Smart 06/22/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Glory Road 01/22/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Goal! The Dream Begins 05/14/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Golden Compass 12/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Gone Baby Gone (see key) 10/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
The Good German 12/17/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Good Luck Chuck (see key) 09/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Good Night, And Good Luck 10/09/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Thompson)
thumbs up
 
The Good Shepherd (see key) 12/24/2006
  thumbs down
(Ramis)
thumbs up
 
A Good Year 11/12/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down The Gospel 10/09/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Goya's Ghosts 07/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Grace Is Gone 12/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Gracie 06/03/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Grand 03/23/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Gray Matters 03/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Great Debaters 12/23/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down The Greatest Game Ever Played 10/02/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Great Raid 08/07/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Green Street Hooligans 09/11/2005
  thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs down
 
Gridiron Gang 09/17/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Grindhouse* (see key) 04/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Grizzly Man 08/14/2005
  thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs down
 
The Guardian (see key) 10/01/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Guess Who (see key) 03/27/2005
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
A Guide To Recognizing Your Saints 10/22/2006
 
H
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Hairspray 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Half Nelson 08/13/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Hammer 03/23/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Hancock 07/13/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Happening 06/15/2008
  thumbs down thumbs up Happy Endings 07/17/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Happy Feet 11/19/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Hard Candy 04/16/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Harold & Kumar Escape From Guantanamo Bay 04/27/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire 11/20/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix 07/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Ramis)
thumbs down
 
Harsh Times 11/12/2006
  thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs down
 
Haven 09/17/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Heartbreak Kid (see key) 10/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Heart Of The Game 06/18/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Heights 06/19/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Hellboy II: The Golden Army 07/13/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Hell Ride 08/10/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Henry Poole Is Here 08/17/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Herbie Fully Loaded 06/26/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Hide And Seek 01/30/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down High Tension 06/12/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down The Hills Have Eyes# (see key) 03/12/2006
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The History Boys 11/26/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up A History Of Violence (see key) 09/25/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Hitch 02/13/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down The Hitchhiker's Guide to The Galaxy 05/01/2005
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Hitman 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Hoax* (see key) 04/08/2007
  thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs down
 
The Holiday 12/10/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Hollywoodland 09/03/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
Home Of The Brave 12/17/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Honeydripper 01/06/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down The Honeymooners 06/12/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Hoodwinked 12/25/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Hoot# (see key) 05/07/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Horton Hears A Who! 03/16/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
The Host 03/11/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Hostage 03/13/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)

 
Hostel: Part II (see key) 01/13/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Hot Fuzz* (see key) 04/15/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Hot Rod 08/05/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Hottest State 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Hottie And The Nottie 02/10/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down House Of D 04/17/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up House Of Wax 05/08/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Howl's Moving Castle 06/12/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
How The Garcia Girls Spent Their Summer 05/18/2008
  thumbs down
(Senecal)
thumbs down
 
How To Eat Fried Worms (see key) 08/27/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Hunting Party 09/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Hustle & Flow 07/24/2005
 
I
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I Am Legend 12/16/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Ice Age: The Meltdown 04/02/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
L'Iceberg 05/27/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Ice Harvest 11/27/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down Ice Princess 03/20/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
I Could Never Be Your Woman 02/17/2008
  thumbs up
(Senecal)
thumbs down
 
Idlewild 08/27/2006
    thumbs down I Know Who Killed Me (see key) 01/13/2008
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Illegal Tender 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Ridley)
thumbs up
 
The Illusionist 08/20/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Imaginary Heroes 02/13/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I'm Not There (see key) 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
In Bruges* (see key) 02/10/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up An Inconvenient Truth 06/04/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Incredible Hulk 06/15/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull 05/25/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Infamous 10/15/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up In Good Company 01/09/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up In Her Shoes 10/09/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down In My Country 03/13/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry (see key) 07/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Inside Deep Throat 02/13/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Inside Man 03/26/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Interpreter 04/17/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Interview 07/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs up
 
In The Land Of Women 04/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up In The Realms Of The Unreal 01/23/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
In The Shadow Of The Moon 09/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
In The Valley Of Elah 09/16/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Into The Blue 10/02/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Into The Wild (see key) 09/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Introducing The Dwights 07/29/2007
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
The Invasion 08/19/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Ridley)
thumbs up
 
Invincible 08/20/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Iron Man* (see key) 04/27/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down The Island 07/24/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
I Think I Love My Wife 03/11/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down It's All Gone Pete Tong 05/01/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I Want Someone To Eat Cheese With 10/21/2007
 
J
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Willard)
thumbs up
 
Jackass: Number 2 09/24/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down The Jacket 03/06/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Jane Austen Book Club 10/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Jarhead 11/06/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Kit)
thumbs up
 
Jesus Camp 10/08/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Willard)
thumbs up
 
Jet Li's Fearless 09/24/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Jiminy Glick In La La Wood 05/08/2005
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Jimmy Carter Man From Plains 11/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Journey To The Center Of The Earth 06/29/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Joyeux Noel 03/05/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Jumper 02/17/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Junebug (see key) 08/07/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Juno (see key) 12/02/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Just Friends 11/27/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Just Like Heaven 09/18/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Just My Luck# (see key) 05/28/2006
 
K
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Keane 09/18/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Kit)
thumbs up
 
Keeping Mum 10/08/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Keeping Up With The Steins 05/14/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Kicking And Screaming 05/08/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Kid & I 12/04/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down Kids In America 10/23/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Killer Diller 05/07/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The King 05/21/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Kingdom 09/30/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Kingdom Of Heaven 05/01/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up King Kong (see key) 12/11/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
King Of California 09/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The King Of Kong 08/26/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Kinky Boots 04/16/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang 10/30/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Kite Runner 12/16/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Kit Kittredge: An American Girl 06/22/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Knocked Up* (see key) 05/27/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Kung Fu Hustle 04/10/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Kung Fu Panda* (see key) 06/01/2008
 
L
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Lackawanna Blues 01/30/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Ladies in Lavender 05/01/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Lake House 06/11/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Land Of The Dead 06/26/2005
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Lars And The Real Girl (see key) 10/14/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Lassie 09/03/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Last Days 07/24/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Last Holiday 01/08/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
The Last King Of Scotland 10/01/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
The Last Kiss 09/10/2006
  thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
The Last Mimzy 03/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Layer Cake 06/19/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Leatherheads 04/06/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Left Of The Dial 04/03/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down The Legend Of Zorro (see key) 10/30/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
Letters From Iwo Jima (see key) 12/17/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down The Libertine 01/08/2006
    thumbs down License To Wed (see key) 01/13/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Life Before Her Eyes 04/20/2008
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Lions For Lambs 11/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Little Children (see key) 10/15/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Leno)
thumbs up
 
Little Miss Sunshine (see key) 08/06/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs up
 
Live Free Or Die Hard 07/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
The Lives Of Others* (see key) 02/18/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Loggerheads 10/30/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down London (see key) 02/12/2006
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Lonely Hearts 04/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Lonesome Jim 03/26/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down The Longest Yard (see key) 05/29/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Look Both Ways 05/14/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Looking For Comedy In The Muslim World 01/22/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Senecal)
thumbs up
 
Looking For Kitty 08/27/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
The Lookout* (see key) 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Lord Of War 09/11/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Lords Of Dogtown 06/05/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Lost City 04/30/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down A Lot Like Love 04/24/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Love Guru 06/22/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Love In The Time Of Cholera 11/18/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Loverboy 06/18/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up A Love Song For Bobby Long 01/09/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Lucky Number Slevin 04/09/2006
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Lucky You 05/06/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Lust, Caution 09/30/2007
 
M
  thumbs down thumbs down Madagascar 05/29/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Made Of Honor 05/04/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Mad Hot Ballroom 06/19/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down Madison 04/24/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Mad Money 01/20/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Mama Mia! 07/20/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down The Man (see key) 09/11/2005
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Man Of The Year 10/15/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down March Of The Penguins 06/26/2005
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Margot At The Wedding 11/18/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Marie Antoinette 10/22/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Marilyn Hotchiss' Ballroom Dancing And Charm School 04/02/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Married Life 03/09/2008
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Martian Child 11/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Matador 01/08/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Match Point 12/18/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Maxed Out 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Me And You And Everyone We Know (see key) 06/19/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Meet Bill 05/11/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Meet Dave 07/13/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Meet the Robinsons 04/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Melinda And Melinda 03/20/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Memoirs Of A Geisha 12/11/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down The Memory Of A Killer 09/25/2005
  thumbs up
(Leno)
thumbs down
 
Miami Vice 08/06/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Michael Clayton (see key) 10/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
A Mighty Heart 06/17/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Millions (see key) 03/13/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Mindhunters 05/15/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Mirrormask 10/02/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Miss Congeniality 2: Armed And Fabulous (see key) 03/27/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Mission: Impossible III 05/28/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Miss Pettigrew Lives For A Day 03/09/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Miss Potter 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Mist 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Mondovino 04/10/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Mongol 06/22/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Monster House 07/02/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Monster-In-Law (see key) 05/15/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Mr. And Mrs. Smith 06/12/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Bean's Holiday 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Mr. Brooks 06/03/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium 11/18/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Mrs. Henderson Presents 12/11/2005
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Woodcock 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Mummy: Tomb Of The Dragon Emperor 08/03/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Munich (see key) 12/18/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Murderball 07/17/2005
  thumbs down
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Music & Lyrics 02/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Music Within 10/28/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Must Love Dogs 07/31/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
My Best Friend 07/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
My Blueberry Nights 04/13/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
My Kid Could Paint That 10/14/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Mysterious Skin 06/05/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up My Summer Of Love 07/03/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
  My Super Ex-Girlfriend (see key) 01/14/2007
 
N
  thumbs down thumbs down Nacho Libre# (see key) 06/18/2006
  thumbs down
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
The Namesake 03/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Nancy Drew 06/17/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Nanny Diaries 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
National Treasure:
Book Of Secrets
12/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Sagal)
thumbs up
 
The Nativity Story 12/03/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Never Back Down# (see key) 03/16/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The New World (see key) 12/18/2005
  thumbs up
(Thompson)
thumbs down
 
Night At The Museum 12/24/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Leno)
thumbs up
 
The Night Listener 08/06/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Nim's Island 04/06/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Nine Lives (see key) 10/23/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
No Country For Old Men (see key) 11/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
No End In Sight 07/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Noise 05/11/2008
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs down
 
Norbit (see key) 02/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
No Reservations 07/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up North Country 10/16/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Notes On A Scandal (see key) 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Notorious Bettie Page 04/16/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up November 07/24/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Pennacchio)
thumbs up
 
The Number 23 (see key) 02/25/2007
 
O
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Ocean's Thirteen (see key) 06/03/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Off The Map 03/13/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down Oliver Twist 09/25/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Omen 06/04/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up On A Clear Day 04/09/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Once* (see key) 05/20/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Ong Bak: The Thai Warrior 02/13/2005
  thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs down
 
Open Season 10/01/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Orphanage 01/06/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Other Boleyn Girl 03/02/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Over The Hedge 05/21/2006
 
P
  thumbs down thumbs down The Pacifier 03/06/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Palindromes 04/17/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Pan's Labyrinth (see key) 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Paradise Now 11/20/2005
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Paranoid Park 03/16/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Paris Je T'aime (see key) 06/03/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Peaceful Warrior 06/04/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Penelope 03/02/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Perfect Holiday 12/16/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down The Perfect Man 06/19/2005
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Perfect Stranger (see key) 04/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Perfume: The Story Of A Murderer 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Persepolis 01/06/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Pineapple Express 08/10/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down The Pink Panther# (see key) 02/12/2006
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Pirates Of The Caribbean: At World's End 05/27/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Poseidon 05/28/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down A Prairie Home Companion* (see key) 06/11/2006
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Premonition 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Prestige 10/22/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Pretty Persuasion 08/28/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs up
 
Pride 03/25/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Pride And Prejudice 11/13/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Prime 10/30/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down The Prizewinner Of Defiance Ohio 10/02/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Producers 12/11/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Promotion 06/15/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Proof 09/04/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Proposition* (see key) 05/07/2006
  thumbs down
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
The Protector 09/10/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Provoked 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
P.S. I Love You 12/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Puffy Chair 06/04/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Pure 06/19/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Purple Violets 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
The Pursuit Of Happyness 12/17/2006
 
Q
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
The Queen (see key) 10/01/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Quiet 09/03/2006
 
R
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Rail & Ties 11/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs up
 
Ratatouille (see key) 07/01/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down The Real Dirt On Farmer John 02/12/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Reaping (see key) 04/08/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Rebound 07/03/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Recount* (see key) 05/25/2008
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Redacted 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Redbelt 05/04/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Red Eye 08/28/2005
  thumbs down
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
Reign Over Me 03/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Rendition 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Pennacchio)
thumbs up
 
Reno 911!: Miami 02/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Rent 11/27/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Reprise* (see key) 05/18/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Rescue Dawn 06/24/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Reservation Road 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Resurrecting The Champ 08/26/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down The Ringer 12/25/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down The Ring Two 03/20/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down Rize 06/26/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Road To Guantanamo 06/25/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Robots 03/13/2005
  thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Rocket Science 08/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Rock School 06/05/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Rocker 08/17/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
Rocky Balboa 12/17/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Roll, Bounce 09/25/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Roman Polanski: Wanted And Desired 07/13/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Rory O'Shea Was Here 01/30/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Rumor Has It 12/18/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Run Fatboy Run 03/30/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down Running Scared 02/26/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Running With Scissors (see key) 10/29/2006
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Rush Hour 3 (see key) 08/12/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down RV# (see key) 04/30/2006
 
S
  thumbs up thumbs down Sahara 04/10/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Saint Ralph 08/07/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Saraband 07/17/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Sarah Silverman: Jesus Is Magic 11/13/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Savage Grace 06/01/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Savages (see key) 12/02/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Saving Shiloh 05/21/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Say Uncle 06/25/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up A Scanner Darkly 06/25/2006
    thumbs up School For Scoundrels 10/01/2006
  thumbs down
(Willard)
thumbs down
 
The Science Of Sleep 09/24/2006
  thumbs down
(Smith)
thumbs down
 
Scoop 08/13/2006
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Seeker: The Dark Is Rising 10/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Self Medicated 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Semi-Pro 03/02/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Sentinel 04/23/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Separate Lies 10/16/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Seraphim Falls 01/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Serenity 10/02/2005
  thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Severance 05/27/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Sex And Death 101 04/06/2008
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Sex And The City 06/01/2008
  thumbs up
(Leno)
thumbs down
 
Shadowboxer 08/06/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down The Shaggy Dog (see key) 03/12/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tyler)
thumbs up
 
sherrybaby 09/10/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down She's The Man 03/19/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Shine A Light 04/06/2008
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Shoot 'Em Up (see key) 09/09/2007
  thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
Shooter 03/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Shopgirl 10/23/2005
  thumbs down
(Kit)
thumbs up
 
Shortbus 10/08/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Shrek The Third 05/20/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Shut Up And Sing 10/29/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
SiCKO 06/24/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Simpsons Movie 07/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Sin City 04/03/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Sir! No Sir! 04/09/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Sisterhood Of The Traveling Pants 05/22/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Sisterhood Of The Traveling Pants 2 08/10/2008
  thumbs down thumbs up The Sisters 04/16/2006
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
The Situation 02/11/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down 16 Blocks 03/05/2006
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Sixty Six 08/03/2008
  thumbs down thumbs up The Skeleton Key 08/14/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Sketches Of Frank Gehry 06/11/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Sleepwalking 03/23/2008
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sleuth 10/14/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down Slither 04/02/2006
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Smarter For 10 03/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Smart People 04/13/2008
  thumbs up
(Senecal)
thumbs down
 
Snakes On A Plane 08/27/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Snow Angels* (see key) 03/09/2008
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Snow Cake 04/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Son Of Rambow 05/04/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Son Of The Mask (see key) 02/20/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Sorry, Haters 03/05/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Southland Tales (see key) 11/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Space Chimps 07/20/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Speed Racer 05/11/2008
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
Spider-Man 3 05/06/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Spiderwick Chronicles 02/17/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Squid And The Whale 10/16/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Standard Operating Procedure 05/04/2008
  thumbs down thumbs up Standing Still 04/23/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Stardust 08/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Starting Out In The Evening 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Star Wars Episode III: The Revenge Of The Sith 05/15/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Star Wars: The Clone Wars 08/17/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down Stay 10/23/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Stealth (see key) 07/31/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Steamboy 03/20/2005
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Step Brothers 07/27/2008
  thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs down
 
Step Up 08/13/2006
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Step Up 2 The Streets 02/17/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Stick It# (see key) 04/30/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Stop-Loss 03/30/2008
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Strangers 06/01/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Strangers With Candy 07/02/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Van Peebles)
thumbs up
 
Stranger Than Fiction 11/05/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Street Kings 04/13/2008
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sunshine 07/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Superbad (see key) 08/05/2007
  thumbs down thumbs up Superman Returns 07/02/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Surf's Up 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Sweeney Todd (see key) 12/16/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Sagal)
thumbs up
 
Sweetland 12/03/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Swing Vote 08/03/2008
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sydney White 09/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Syriana (see key) 11/20/2005
 
T
  thumbs up thumbs down Take The Lead 04/09/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down The Talent Given Us 06/19/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Talk To Me 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Leno)
thumbs up
 
Talladega Nights: The Ballad Of Ricky Bobby 08/06/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Taxi To The Dark Side 02/25/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Tell No One 07/20/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Ten 08/05/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Tenacious D In The Pick Of Destiny 11/26/2006
  thumbs down
(Sagal)
thumbs up
 
10 Items Or Less 12/03/2006
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
10,000 B.C.# (see key) 03/16/2008
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
Terror's Advocate (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Kit)
thumbs down
 
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning 10/08/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Thank You For Smoking* (see key) 03/19/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Then She Found Me 05/04/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
There Will Be Blood (see key) 01/06/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Things We Lost In The Fire 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
30 Days Of Night 10/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
This Christmas 11/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
This Film Is Not Yet Rated 09/03/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Three Burials Of Melquiades Estrada* (see key) 01/22/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Three Extremes 11/06/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
300* (see key) 03/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
3:10 To Yuma 09/02/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)
  Three Times (see key) 12/31/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Thumbsucker 09/18/2005
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Tideland 10/15/2006
  thumbs down
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
TMNT 03/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Tracey Fragments 05/18/2008
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Trade 09/30/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Transamerica 12/04/2005
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Transformers 07/15/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Transporter 2 09/04/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Transsiberian 07/20/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down Tristan & Isolde 01/22/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Tristram Shandy: A Cock And Bull Story* (see key) 02/19/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Tropic Thunder 08/17/2008
  thumbs down
(Ridley)
thumbs down
 
Trust The Man 08/20/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Tsotsi 02/26/2006
  thumbs down
(Sagal)
thumbs down
 
Turistas 12/03/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Twelve And Holding 06/04/2006
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
12:08 East Of Bucharest (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
28 Weeks Later 05/13/2007
  thumbs down thumbs up 2046 08/07/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
21 03/30/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
27 Dresses 01/20/2008
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
2 Days In Paris 08/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Two For The Money 10/09/2005
 
U
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
The Ultimate Gift 03/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Tyler)
thumbs down
 
Unaccompanied Minors (see key) 12/10/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Undead (see key) 07/10/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Underclassman 09/04/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Under The Same Moon 03/23/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up An Unfinished Life 09/04/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up United 93* (see key) 04/30/2006
  thumbs down
(Van Peebles)
thumbs up
 
Unknown 11/05/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Unknown White Male 02/19/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down Unleashed 05/15/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Upside Of Anger 03/06/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
U2 3D 01/20/2008
 
V
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Vacancy 04/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Vantage Point 02/25/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Thompson)
thumbs up
 
Venus 12/24/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up V For Vendetta 03/19/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Vicky Cristina Barcelona 08/10/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Vince Vaughn's Wild West Comedy Show 02/10/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Visitor* (see key) 04/20/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Van Peebles)
thumbs up
 
Volver (see key) 11/05/2006
 
W
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Wackness 07/13/2008
  thumbs up thumbs down Wah-wah 05/14/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down Waiting... 10/09/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Waitress 04/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Walk Hard 12/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Walk The Line (see key) 11/13/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down Wallace And Gromit: The Curse Of The Were-Rabbit 10/09/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
WALL-E 06/22/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Wal-Mart: The High Cost Of Low Price 11/13/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Wanted 06/29/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
War, Inc. 05/25/2008
  thumbs down thumbs up War Of The Worlds 07/03/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The War Within 11/20/2005
  thumbs up thumbs down Wassup Rockers (see key) 06/25/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Water 04/30/2006
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Water Horse:
Legend Of The Deep
01/06/2008
  thumbs down
(Thompson)
thumbs up
 
We Are Marshall 12/24/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Weatherman 10/30/2005
  thumbs down thumbs up Wedding Crashers 07/17/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down The Wedding Date 02/13/2005
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Welcome Home, Roscoe Jenkins 02/10/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Wendell Baker Story 05/20/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
We Own The Night 10/14/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
What Happens In Vegas 05/11/2008
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
What Love Is 04/01/2007
  thumbs down thumbs down When Do We Eat? 04/23/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Where In The World Is Osama Bin Laden? 04/20/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Where The Truth Lies 10/16/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The White Countess 12/25/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Who Killed The Electric Car? 07/02/2006
  thumbs down thumbs up Why We Fight 01/22/2006
  thumbs down
(Tyler)
thumbs down
 
The Wicker Man 09/10/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down The Wild 04/16/2006
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Wild Hogs (see key) 03/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up The Wild Parrots Of Telegraph Hill 03/27/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
The Wind That Shakes The Barley 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Winter Passing 02/19/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Winter Solstice 04/10/2005
  thumbs down thumbs down Wolf Creek 12/25/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Wordplay 06/25/2006
  thumbs up thumbs down The World's Fastest Indian 12/18/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
World Trade Center 08/13/2006
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Wristcutters: A Love Story 11/04/2007
 
X
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The X-Files: I Want To Believe 07/27/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up X-Men: The Last Stand 05/28/2006
  thumbs down thumbs down XXX: State Of The Union 05/01/2005
 
Y
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Year Of The Dog 04/15/2007
  thumbs up thumbs down Yes (see key) 06/26/2005
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
You Don't Mess With The Zohan 06/15/2008
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
You Kill Me 06/24/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Young At Heart* (see key) 04/13/2008
  thumbs down thumbs down Yours, Mine And Ours 11/27/2005
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Youth Without Youth 12/16/2007
 
Z
both thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up Zathura 11/13/2005
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Zodiac* (see key) 03/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Zombie Strippers 04/27/2008

 

bold = best of the year

italic = worst of the year

* = best of the year so far

# = worst of the year so far

 

complete listing of Ebert, Siskel, & Roeper's annual top ten lists

 

this page last modified 09/12/2008
Valid XHTML 1.0 Strict Valid CSS!
feedback: webmaster@kplusb.org