Thumbs Summary 2007
 2006 |
2008  |
| Where are the latest reviews? | |
| BOTH THUMBS UP |
EBERT | ROEPER | MOVIE TITLE |
SHOW DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (sorted by) | ||||
| A | ||||
 (Wilonsky) |
 |
Across The Universe | 09/16/2007 | |
(Murty) |
|
Alone With Her | 01/21/2007 | |
(Murty) |
|
Alpha Dog | 01/21/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Alvin And The Chipmunks | 12/16/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
The Amateurs | 12/09/2007 | |
(Pennacchio) |
|
Amazing Grace | 02/25/2007 | |
 |
(Phillips) |
|
American Gangster (see key) | 10/28/2007 |
(Scott) |
|
Aqua Teen Hunger Force | 04/15/2007 | |
(Hunter) |
|
Arctic Tale | 08/19/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Are We Done Yet? | 04/08/2007 | |
(Murty) |
|
Arthur And The Invisibles | 01/21/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Assassination Of Jesse James | 09/23/2007 | |
|
(Schwarzbaum) |
|
The Astronaut Farmer | 02/11/2007 |
(Scott) |
|
Atonement | 12/09/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
August Rush | 11/25/2007 | |
|
(Silberling) |
|
Away From Her* (see key) | 05/13/2007 |
| B | ||||
(Wilonsky) |
|
Balls Of Fury | 09/02/2007 | |
(Schwarzbaum) |
|
Because I Said So (see key) | 02/11/2007 | |
(Karger) |
|
Becoming Jane | 08/12/2007 | |
|
(Scott) |
|
Bee Movie | 11/04/2007 |
|
(Phillips) |
|
Before The Devil Knows You're Dead | 10/28/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Beowulf | 11/18/2007 | |
|
(Morgan) |
|
Beyond The Gates | 03/11/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Black Sheep | 06/24/2007 | |
|
(Smith) |
|
Black Snake Moan | 02/18/2007 |
(Lemire) |
|
Blades Of Glory | 04/01/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
The Bourne Ultimatum | 07/29/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Bratz (see key) | 08/05/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Brave One | 09/16/2007 | |
|
(Smith) |
|
Breach | 02/18/2007 |
|
(Smith) |
|
Bridge To Terabithia | 02/18/2007 |
|
(Karger) |
|
Broken English | 07/15/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Brothers Solomon | 09/09/2007 | |
(Edelstein) |
|
Bug | 05/27/2007 | |
| C | ||||
(Phillips) |
|
El Cantante | 08/05/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Cashback | 07/29/2007 | |
|
(Murty) |
|
Catch And Release | 01/21/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Charlie Wilson's War | 12/23/2007 | |
|
(Silberling) |
|
Civic Duty | 05/13/2007 |
(Lemire) |
|
The Condemned | 04/29/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
Control | 10/28/2007 |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
Crazy Love | 06/03/2007 |
(Scott) |
|
Curse Of The Golden Flower | 01/07/2007 | |
| D | ||||
(Karger) |
|
Daddy Day Camp | 08/12/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
Dan In Real Life | 10/28/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
Darfur Now | 11/12/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Darjeeling Limited | 09/30/2007 | |
(Hunter) |
|
Death At A Funeral | 08/19/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Death Sentence | 09/02/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
December Boys | 10/07/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Dedication | 09/02/2007 | |
|
(Hunter) |
|
Delirious | 08/19/2007 |
|
(Lemire) |
|
Diggers | 04/29/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
Disturbia | 04/15/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
The Diving Bell And The Butterfly | 12/02/2007 |
| E | ||||
(Tulich) |
|
Eagle Vs. Shark | 07/01/2007 | |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
Eastern Promises | 09/09/2007 |
(Hunter) |
|
The 11th Hour | 08/19/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Elizabeth: The Golden Age | 10/14/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
Enchanted | 11/18/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Evan Almighty | 06/24/2007 | |
(Tulich) |
|
Evening | 07/01/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Even Money | 05/20/2007 | |
(Silberling) |
|
The Ex | 05/13/2007 | |
| F | ||||
(Schwarzbaum) |
|
Factory Girl | 02/11/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Fantastic 4: Rise Of The Silver Surfer | 06/17/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Feast Of Love | 09/30/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Fido | 06/17/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Fierce People | 09/09/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Firehouse Dog | 04/08/2007 | |
|
First Snow | 04/08/2007 | ||
(Scott) |
4 Months, 3 Weeks And 2 Days (see key) | 12/30/2007 | ||
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
1408 | 06/17/2007 |
(Mellencamp) |
|
Fracture | 04/22/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Fred Claus | 11/12/2007 | |
| G | ||||
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Game Plan | 09/30/2007 | |
(Silberling) |
|
Georgia Rule# (see key) | 05/13/2007 | |
|
(Scott) |
|
The Golden Compass | 12/09/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Gone Baby Gone (see key) | 10/21/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Good Luck Chuck (see key) | 09/23/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Goya's Ghosts | 07/22/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Grace Is Gone | 12/09/2007 | |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
Gracie | 06/03/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Gray Matters | 03/04/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
The Great Debaters | 12/23/2007 |
|
(Lemire) |
|
Grindhouse* (see key) | 04/01/2007 |
| H | ||||
|
(Karger) |
|
Hairspray | 07/15/2007 |
|
(Karger) |
|
Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix | 07/15/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Heartbreak Kid (see key) | 10/07/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Hitman | 12/02/2007 | |
|
(Scott) |
|
The Hoax* (see key) | 04/08/2007 |
|
(Morgan) |
|
The Host | 03/11/2007 |
(Phillips) |
Hostel: Part II (see key) | 01/13/2008 | ||
|
(Scott) |
|
Hot Fuzz* (see key) | 04/15/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Hot Rod | 08/05/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Hottest State | 09/16/2007 | |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Hunting Party | 09/02/2007 |
| I | ||||
|
(Phillips) |
|
I Am Legend | 12/16/2007 |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
L'Iceberg | 05/27/2007 |
|
I Know Who Killed Me (see key) | 01/13/2008 | ||
(Wilonsky) |
|
Illegal Tender | 08/26/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
I'm Not There (see key) | 11/25/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry (see key) | 07/22/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Interview | 07/22/2007 | |
|
(Mellencamp) |
|
In The Land Of Women | 04/22/2007 |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
In The Shadow Of The Moon | 09/09/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
In The Valley Of Elah | 09/16/2007 | |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
Into The Wild (see key) | 09/23/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Introducing The Dwights | 07/29/2007 | |
(Hunter) |
|
The Invasion | 08/19/2007 | |
|
(Morgan) |
|
I Think I Love My Wife | 03/11/2007 |
|
(Phillips) |
|
I Want Someone To Eat Cheese With | 10/21/2007 |
| J | ||||
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Jane Austen Book Club | 10/07/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Jimmy Carter Man From Plains | 11/04/2007 | |
|
(Scott) |
|
Juno (see key) | 12/02/2007 |
| K | ||||
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Kingdom | 09/30/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
King Of California | 09/23/2007 | |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
The King Of Kong | 08/26/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
The Kite Runner | 12/16/2007 | |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
Knocked Up* (see key) | 05/27/2007 |
| L | ||||
(Wilonsky) |
|
Lars And The Real Girl (see key) | 10/14/2007 | |
(Morris) |
|
The Last Mimzy | 03/25/2007 | |
|
License To Wed (see key) | 01/13/2008 | ||
(Scott) |
|
Lions For Lambs | 11/12/2007 | |
|
(Tulich) |
|
Live Free Or Die Hard | 07/01/2007 |
|
(Smith) |
|
The Lives Of Others* (see key) | 02/18/2007 |
(Mellencamp) |
|
Lonely Hearts | 04/22/2007 | |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
The Lookout* (see key) | 03/18/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Love In The Time Of Cholera | 11/18/2007 | |
(Lemire) |
|
Lucky You | 05/06/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Lust, Caution | 09/30/2007 | |
| M | ||||
(Phillips) |
|
Margot At The Wedding | 11/18/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Martian Child | 11/04/2007 | |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
Maxed Out | 03/18/2007 |
|
(Lemire) |
|
Meet the Robinsons | 04/01/2007 |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
Michael Clayton (see key) | 10/07/2007 |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
A Mighty Heart | 06/17/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
Miss Potter | 01/07/2007 |
|
(Phillips) |
|
The Mist | 11/25/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Mr. Bean's Holiday | 08/26/2007 | |
(Edelstein) |
|
Mr. Brooks | 06/03/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium | 11/18/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Mr. Woodcock | 09/16/2007 | |
(Smith) |
|
Music & Lyrics | 02/18/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Music Within | 10/28/2007 | |
|
(Karger) |
|
My Best Friend | 07/15/2007 |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
My Kid Could Paint That | 10/14/2007 |
| N | ||||
(Morgan) |
|
The Namesake | 03/11/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Nancy Drew | 06/17/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Nanny Diaries | 08/26/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
National Treasure: Book Of Secrets |
12/23/2007 | |
|
(Scott) |
|
No Country For Old Men (see key) | 11/04/2007 |
|
(Phillips) |
|
No End In Sight | 07/29/2007 |
(Schwarzbaum) |
|
Norbit# (see key) | 02/11/2007 | |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
No Reservations | 07/22/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
Notes On A Scandal | 01/07/2007 |
|
(Pennacchio) |
|
The Number 23 (see key) | 02/25/2007 |
| O | ||||
|
(Edelstein) |
|
Ocean's Thirteen (see key) | 06/03/2007 |
|
(Phillips) |
|
Once* (see key) | 05/20/2007 |
| P | ||||
|
(Scott) |
|
The Painted Veil | 01/07/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
Pan's Labyrinth | 01/07/2007 |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
Paris Je T'aime (see key) | 06/03/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Perfect Holiday | 12/16/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Perfect Stranger (see key) | 04/15/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Perfume: The Story Of A Murderer | 01/07/2007 | |
(Edelstein) |
|
Pirates Of The Caribbean: At World's End | 05/27/2007 | |
(Edelstein) |
|
Premonition | 03/18/2007 | |
|
(Morris) |
|
Pride | 03/25/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Provoked | 05/20/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
P.S. I Love You | 12/23/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Purple Violets | 11/25/2007 | |
| R | ||||
(Scott) |
|
Rail & Ties | 11/12/2007 | |
|
(Tulich) |
|
Ratatouille (see key) | 07/01/2007 |
(Scott) |
|
The Reaping (see key) | 04/08/2007 | |
(Scott) |
|
Redacted | 12/02/2007 | |
(Morris) |
|
Reign Over Me | 03/25/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Rendition | 10/21/2007 | |
(Pennacchio) |
|
Reno 911!: Miami | 02/25/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Rescue Dawn | 06/24/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Reservation Road | 10/21/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Resurrecting The Champ | 08/26/2007 | |
(Karger) |
|
Rocket Science | 08/12/2007 | |
(Karger) |
|
Rush Hour 3 (see key) | 08/12/2007 | |
| S | ||||
|
(Scott) |
|
The Savages (see key) | 12/02/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
The Seeker: The Dark Is Rising | 10/07/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Self Medicated | 09/02/2007 | |
|
(Murty) |
|
Seraphim Falls | 01/21/2007 |
(Edelstein) |
|
Severance | 05/27/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Shoot 'Em Up (see key) | 09/09/2007 | |
(Morris) |
|
Shooter | 03/25/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Shrek The Third | 05/20/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
SiCKO | 06/24/2007 |
|
(Phillips) |
|
The Simpsons Movie | 07/29/2007 |
(Schwarzbaum) |
|
The Situation | 02/11/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Sleuth | 10/14/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Smarter For 10 | 03/04/2007 | |
(Lemire) |
|
Snow Cake | 04/29/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Southland Tales (see key) | 11/18/2007 | |
(Lemire) |
|
Spider-Man 3 | 05/06/2007 | |
|
(Karger) |
|
Stardust | 08/12/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
Starting Out In The Evening | 12/02/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Sunshine | 07/22/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
Superbad (see key) | 08/05/2007 |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
Surf's Up | 06/03/2007 |
|
(Phillips) |
|
Sweeney Todd (see key) | 12/16/2007 |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Sydney White | 09/23/2007 | |
| T | ||||
|
(Karger) |
|
Talk To Me | 07/15/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
The Ten | 08/05/2007 | |
(Scott) |
Terror's Advocate (see key) | 12/30/2007 | ||
(Scott) |
There Will Be Blood (see key) | 12/30/2007 | ||
|
(Phillips) |
|
Things We Lost In The Fire | 10/21/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
30 Days Of Night | 10/21/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
This Christmas | 11/25/2007 |
|
(Morgan) |
|
300* (see key) | 03/11/2007 |
|
(Wilonsky) |
|
3:10 To Yuma | 09/02/2007 |
(Morris) |
|
TMNT | 03/25/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
Trade | 09/30/2007 | |
(Karger) |
|
Transformers | 07/15/2007 | |
(Scott) |
12:08 East Of Bucharest (see key) | 12/30/2007 | ||
(Silberling) |
|
28 Weeks Later | 05/13/2007 | |
(Karger) |
|
2 Days In Paris | 08/12/2007 | |
| U | ||||
(Edelstein) |
|
The Ultimate Gift | 03/18/2007 | |
| V | ||||
(Mellencamp) |
|
Vacancy | 04/22/2007 | |
| W | ||||
|
(Lemire) |
|
Waitress | 04/29/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
Walk Hard | 12/09/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
The Wendell Baker Story | 05/20/2007 | |
(Wilonsky) |
|
We Own The Night | 10/14/2007 | |
(Lemire) |
|
What Love Is | 04/01/2007 | |
(Phillips) |
|
Wild Hogs (see key) | 03/04/2007 | |
|
(Edelstein) |
|
The Wind That Shakes The Barley | 03/18/2007 |
|
(Scott) |
|
Wristcutters: A Love Story | 11/04/2007 |
| Y | ||||
(Scott) |
|
Year Of The Dog | 04/15/2007 | |
|
(Phillips) |
|
You Kill Me | 06/24/2007 |
(Phillips) |
|
Youth Without Youth | 12/16/2007 | |
| Z | ||||
|
(Phillips) |
|
Zodiac* (see key) | 03/04/2007 |
bold = best of the year (12/30/2007 Roeper & Scott)
italic = worst of the year (01/13/2008 Roeper & Phillips)
* = best of the year so far (06/10/2007 Roeper & Lemire)
# = worst of the year so far (06/10/2007 Roeper & Lemire)
complete listing of Ebert, Siskel, & Roeper's annual top ten lists
this page last modified 02/21/2024
