Ebert & Roeper Thumbs Summary
2007
arrow 2006 2008 arrow
Where is Ebert? / How's he doing?
BOTH
THUMBS
UP
EBERT ROEPER MOVIE
TITLE
SHOW
DATE
(sorted by)        
both thumbs up
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
American Gangster (see key) 10/28/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
The Astronaut Farmer 02/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
Away From Her* (see key) 05/13/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Bee Movie 11/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Before The Devil Knows You're Dead 10/28/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
Beyond The Gates 03/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Black Snake Moan 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Breach 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Bridge To Terabithia 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Broken English 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Bourne Ultimatum 07/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Catch And Release 01/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
Civic Duty 05/13/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Control 10/28/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Crazy Love 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Dan In Real Life 10/28/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Darfur Now 11/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs up
 
Delirious 08/19/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Diggers 04/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Disturbia 04/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Diving Bell And The Butterfly 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Eastern Promises 09/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Enchanted 11/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
1408 06/17/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Golden Compass 12/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Gracie 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Great Debaters 12/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Grindhouse* (see key) 04/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Hairspray 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Hoax* (see key) 04/08/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
The Host 03/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Hot Fuzz* (see key) 04/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Hunting Party 09/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
L'Iceberg 05/27/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I Am Legend 12/16/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I'm Not There (see key) 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs up
 
In The Land Of Women 04/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
In The Shadow Of The Moon 09/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
I Think I Love My Wife 03/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Into The Wild (see key) 09/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I Want Someone To Eat Cheese With 10/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Juno (see key) 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The King Of Kong 08/26/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Knocked Up* (see key) 05/27/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs up
 
Live Free Or Die Hard 07/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
The Lives Of Others* (see key) 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
The Lookout* (see key) 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Maxed Out 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Meet the Robinsons 04/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Michael Clayton (see key) 10/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
A Mighty Heart 06/17/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Miss Potter 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Mist 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
My Best Friend 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
My Kid Could Paint That 10/14/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
No Country For Old Men (see key) 11/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
No End In Sight 07/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
No Reservations 07/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Notes On A Scandal 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Pennacchio)
thumbs up
 
The Number 23 (see key) 02/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Ocean's Thirteen (see key) 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Once* (see key) 05/20/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Painted Veil 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Pan's Labyrinth 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Paris Je T'aime (see key) 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs up
 
Pride 03/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs up
 
Ratatouille (see key) 07/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Savages (see key) 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Seraphim Falls 01/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
SiCKO 06/24/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Simpsons Movie 07/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Stardust 08/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Starting Out In The Evening 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Superbad (see key) 08/05/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Surf's Up 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Sweeney Todd (see key) 12/16/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Talk To Me 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Things We Lost In The Fire 10/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
This Christmas 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
300* (see key) 03/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
3:10 To Yuma 09/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Waitress 04/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Walk Hard 12/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
The Wind That Shakes The Barley 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Wristcutters: A Love Story 11/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
You Kill Me 06/24/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Zodiac* (see key) 03/04/2007
 
ebert thumbs up and roeper thumbs down
  thumbs up
(Pennacchio)
thumbs down
 
Amazing Grace 02/25/2007
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
Arctic Tale 08/19/2007
  thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs down
 
Arthur And The Invisibles 01/21/2007
  thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Becoming Jane 08/12/2007
  thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Bug 05/27/2007
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
Death At A Funeral 08/19/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
December Boys 10/07/2007
  thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs down
 
Eagle Vs. Shark 07/01/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Elizabeth: The Golden Age 10/14/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fantastic 4: Rise Of The Silver Surfer 06/17/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Firehouse Dog 04/08/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
4 Months, 3 Weeks And 2 Days (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Fracture 04/22/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Game Plan 09/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs down
 
Georgia Rule# (see key) 05/13/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Hot Rod 08/05/2007
    thumbs down I Know Who Killed Me (see key) 01/13/2008
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
The Invasion 08/19/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Lars And The Real Girl (see key) 10/14/2007
  thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
The Last Mimzy 03/25/2007
    thumbs down License To Wed (see key) 01/13/2008
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Lonely Hearts 04/22/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Margot At The Wedding 11/18/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium 11/18/2007
  thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Rocket Science 08/12/2007
  thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Severance 05/27/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Shoot 'Em Up (see key) 09/09/2007
  thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
Shooter 03/25/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Smarter For 10 03/04/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
Terror's Advocate (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
There Will Be Blood (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
12:08 East Of Bucharest (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Vacancy 04/22/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
We Own The Night 10/14/2007
 
ebert thumbs down and roeper thumbs up
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Across The Universe 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Alpha Dog 01/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Assassination Of Jesse James 09/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Atonement 12/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Beowulf 11/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Blades Of Glory 04/01/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Brave One 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
El Cantante 08/05/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Cashback 07/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Charlie Wilson's War 12/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Curse Of The Golden Flower 01/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Darjeeling Limited 09/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Hunter)
thumbs up
 
The 11th Hour 08/19/2007
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
Factory Girl 02/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Feast Of Love 09/30/2007
    thumbs up First Snow 04/08/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Fred Claus 11/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Gone Baby Gone (see key) 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Grace Is Gone 12/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)

 
Hostel: Part II (see key) 01/13/2008
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Hottest State 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Interview 07/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
In The Valley Of Elah 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Introducing The Dwights 07/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Jane Austen Book Club 10/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Jimmy Carter Man From Plains 11/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Kingdom 09/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Kite Runner 12/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Lions For Lambs 11/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Love In The Time Of Cholera 11/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Lucky You 05/06/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Lust, Caution 09/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Mr. Brooks 06/03/2007
  thumbs down
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Music & Lyrics 02/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
The Namesake 03/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Nancy Drew 06/17/2007
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Pirates Of The Caribbean: At World's End 05/27/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
P.S. I Love You 12/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Purple Violets 11/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Pennacchio)
thumbs up
 
Reno 911!: Miami 02/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Rescue Dawn 06/24/2007
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
The Situation 02/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Snow Cake 04/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Ten 08/05/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Trade 09/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Transformers 07/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
28 Weeks Later 05/13/2007
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
2 Days In Paris 08/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Year Of The Dog 04/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Youth Without Youth 12/16/2007
 
both thumbs down
  thumbs down
(Murty)
thumbs down
 
Alone With Her 01/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Alvin And The Chipmunks 12/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Amateurs 12/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Aqua Teen Hunger Force 04/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Are We Done Yet? 04/08/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
August Rush 11/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Balls Of Fury 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs down
 
Because I Said So (see key) 02/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Black Sheep 06/24/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Bratz (see key) 08/05/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Brothers Solomon 09/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
The Condemned 04/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Daddy Day Camp 08/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Death Sentence 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Dedication 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Evan Almighty 06/24/2007
  thumbs down
(Tulich)
thumbs down
 
Evening 07/01/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Even Money 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Silberling)
thumbs down
 
The Ex 05/13/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fido 06/17/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fierce People 09/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Good Luck Chuck (see key) 09/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Goya's Ghosts 07/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Gray Matters 03/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Heartbreak Kid (see key) 10/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Hitman 12/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Illegal Tender 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry (see key) 07/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
King Of California 09/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Martian Child 11/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Bean's Holiday 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Woodcock 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Music Within 10/28/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Nanny Diaries 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
National Treasure:
Book Of Secrets
12/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs down
 
Norbit# (see key) 02/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Perfect Holiday 12/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Perfect Stranger (see key) 04/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Perfume: The Story Of A Murderer 01/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Premonition 03/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Provoked 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Rail & Ties 11/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Reaping (see key) 04/08/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Redacted 12/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
Reign Over Me 03/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Rendition 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Reservation Road 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Resurrecting The Champ 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Rush Hour 3 (see key) 08/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Seeker: The Dark Is Rising 10/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Self Medicated 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Shrek The Third 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sleuth 10/14/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Southland Tales (see key) 11/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
Spider-Man 3 05/06/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sunshine 07/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sydney White 09/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
30 Days Of Night 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
TMNT 03/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
The Ultimate Gift 03/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Wendell Baker Story 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
What Love Is 04/01/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Wild Hogs (see key) 03/04/2007

 

bold = best of the year (12/30/2007 Roeper & Scott)

italic = worst of the year (01/13/2008 Roeper & Phillips)

* = best of the year so far (06/10/2007 Roeper & Lemire)

# = worst of the year so far (06/10/2007 Roeper & Lemire)

 

complete listing of Ebert, Siskel, & Roeper's annual top ten lists

 

this page last modified 05/07/2008
Valid XHTML 1.0 Strict Valid CSS!
feedback: webmaster@kplusb.org