Ebert & Roeper

Thumbs Summary 2007

arrow 2006 2008 arrow
Where are the latest reviews?
BOTH
THUMBS
UP
EBERT ROEPER MOVIE
TITLE
SHOW
DATE
        (sorted by)
    thumbs down License To Wed (see key) 01/13/2008
    thumbs down I Know Who Killed Me (see key) 01/13/2008
  thumbs down
(Phillips)

 
Hostel: Part II (see key) 01/13/2008
 
 
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
There Will Be Blood (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
12:08 East Of Bucharest (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
Terror's Advocate (see key) 12/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)

 
4 Months, 3 Weeks And 2 Days (see key) 12/30/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
National Treasure:
Book Of Secrets
12/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
P.S. I Love You 12/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Charlie Wilson's War 12/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Great Debaters 12/23/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I Am Legend 12/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Alvin And The Chipmunks 12/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Perfect Holiday 12/16/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Sweeney Todd (see key) 12/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Youth Without Youth 12/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Kite Runner 12/16/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Golden Compass 12/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Amateurs 12/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Atonement 12/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Walk Hard 12/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Grace Is Gone 12/09/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Juno (see key) 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Starting Out In The Evening 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Savages (see key) 12/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Hitman 12/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Diving Bell And The Butterfly 12/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Redacted 12/02/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Mist 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
This Christmas 11/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
August Rush 11/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I'm Not There (see key) 11/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Purple Violets 11/25/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Beowulf 11/18/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Margot At The Wedding 11/18/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium 11/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Enchanted 11/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Southland Tales (see key) 11/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Love In The Time Of Cholera 11/18/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Fred Claus 11/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Darfur Now 11/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Rail & Ties 11/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Lions For Lambs 11/12/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Bee Movie 11/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Wristcutters: A Love Story 11/04/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
No Country For Old Men (see key) 11/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Martian Child 11/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Jimmy Carter Man From Plains 11/04/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
American Gangster (see key) 10/28/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Music Within 10/28/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Before The Devil Knows You're Dead 10/28/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Dan In Real Life 10/28/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Control 10/28/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Gone Baby Gone (see key) 10/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Things We Lost In The Fire 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Rendition 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Reservation Road 10/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
30 Days Of Night 10/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
I Want Someone To Eat Cheese With 10/21/2007
 
 
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Elizabeth: The Golden Age 10/14/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Lars And The Real Girl (see key) 10/14/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sleuth 10/14/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
We Own The Night 10/14/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
My Kid Could Paint That 10/14/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Michael Clayton (see key) 10/07/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
December Boys 10/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Heartbreak Kid (see key) 10/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Jane Austen Book Club 10/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Seeker: The Dark Is Rising 10/07/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Kingdom 09/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Trade 09/30/2007
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Game Plan 09/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Feast Of Love 09/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Darjeeling Limited 09/30/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Lust, Caution 09/30/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Assassination Of Jesse James 09/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
King Of California 09/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Good Luck Chuck (see key) 09/23/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Into The Wild (see key) 09/23/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sydney White 09/23/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Brave One 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Hottest State 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Woodcock 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
In The Valley Of Elah 09/16/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Across The Universe 09/16/2007
 
 
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Shoot 'Em Up (see key) 09/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Eastern Promises 09/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fierce People 09/09/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Brothers Solomon 09/09/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
In The Shadow Of The Moon 09/09/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
3:10 To Yuma 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Death Sentence 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Balls Of Fury 09/02/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The Hunting Party 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Dedication 09/02/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Self Medicated 09/02/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
The Nanny Diaries 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Illegal Tender 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Resurrecting The Champ 08/26/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Mr. Bean's Holiday 08/26/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
The King Of Kong 08/26/2007
 
 
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
The Invasion 08/19/2007
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
Death At A Funeral 08/19/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs up
 
Delirious 08/19/2007
  thumbs down
(Hunter)
thumbs up
 
The 11th Hour 08/19/2007
  thumbs up
(Hunter)
thumbs down
 
Arctic Tale 08/19/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Rush Hour 3 (see key) 08/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Daddy Day Camp 08/12/2007
  thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Becoming Jane 08/12/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Stardust 08/12/2007
  thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs down
 
Rocket Science 08/12/2007
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
2 Days In Paris 08/12/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
El Cantante 08/05/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Ten 08/05/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Hot Rod 08/05/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Superbad (see key) 08/05/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Bratz (see key) 08/05/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Simpsons Movie 07/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Cashback 07/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Introducing The Dwights 07/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
The Bourne Ultimatum 07/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
No End In Sight 07/29/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry (see key) 07/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Goya's Ghosts 07/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Interview 07/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
No Reservations 07/22/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Sunshine 07/22/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Talk To Me 07/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Transformers 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Hairspray 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
Broken English 07/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Karger)
thumbs up
 
My Best Friend 07/15/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs up
 
Live Free Or Die Hard 07/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs up
 
Ratatouille (see key) 07/01/2007
  thumbs up
(Tulich)
thumbs down
 
Eagle Vs. Shark 07/01/2007
  thumbs down
(Tulich)
thumbs down
 
Evening 07/01/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Evan Almighty 06/24/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
You Kill Me 06/24/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Rescue Dawn 06/24/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
SiCKO 06/24/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Black Sheep 06/24/2007
 
 
  thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fantastic 4: Rise Of The Silver Surfer 06/17/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
Nancy Drew 06/17/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
A Mighty Heart 06/17/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Wilonsky)
thumbs up
 
1408 06/17/2007
  thumbs down
(Wilonsky)
thumbs down
 
Fido 06/17/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Mr. Brooks 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Gracie 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Surf's Up 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Ocean's Thirteen (see key) 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Paris Je T'aime (see key) 06/03/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Crazy Love 06/03/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Pirates Of The Caribbean: At World's End 05/27/2007
  thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Bug 05/27/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Knocked Up* (see key) 05/27/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
L'Iceberg 05/27/2007
  thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Severance 05/27/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Shrek The Third 05/20/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Once* (see key) 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Even Money 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
The Wendell Baker Story 05/20/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Provoked 05/20/2007
 
 
  thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs down
 
Georgia Rule# (see key) 05/13/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
Away From Her* (see key) 05/13/2007
  thumbs down
(Silberling)
thumbs down
 
The Ex 05/13/2007
  thumbs down
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
28 Weeks Later 05/13/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Silberling)
thumbs up
 
Civic Duty 05/13/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
Spider-Man 3 05/06/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Lucky You 05/06/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
The Condemned 04/29/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Snow Cake 04/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Waitress 04/29/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Diggers 04/29/2007
 
 
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Vacancy 04/22/2007
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Lonely Hearts 04/22/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs up
 
In The Land Of Women 04/22/2007
  thumbs up
(Mellencamp)
thumbs down
 
Fracture 04/22/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Disturbia 04/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Year Of The Dog 04/15/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Hot Fuzz* (see key) 04/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Perfect Stranger (see key) 04/15/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Aqua Teen Hunger Force 04/15/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
The Reaping (see key) 04/08/2007
  thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Firehouse Dog 04/08/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Are We Done Yet? 04/08/2007
    thumbs up First Snow 04/08/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Hoax* (see key) 04/08/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Blades Of Glory 04/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Meet the Robinsons 04/01/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Lemire)
thumbs up
 
Grindhouse* (see key) 04/01/2007
  thumbs down
(Lemire)
thumbs down
 
What Love Is 04/01/2007
 
 
  thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
Shooter 03/25/2007
  thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
The Last Mimzy 03/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
TMNT 03/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Morris)
thumbs down
 
Reign Over Me 03/25/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morris)
thumbs up
 
Pride 03/25/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
Premonition 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
The Wind That Shakes The Barley 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
The Lookout* (see key) 03/18/2007
  thumbs down
(Edelstein)
thumbs down
 
The Ultimate Gift 03/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Edelstein)
thumbs up
 
Maxed Out 03/18/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
300* (see key) 03/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
The Namesake 03/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
I Think I Love My Wife 03/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
Beyond The Gates 03/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Morgan)
thumbs up
 
The Host 03/11/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs up
 
Zodiac* (see key) 03/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Gray Matters 03/04/2007
  thumbs down
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Wild Hogs (see key) 03/04/2007
  thumbs up
(Phillips)
thumbs down
 
Smarter For 10 03/04/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Pennacchio)
thumbs up
 
The Number 23 (see key) 02/25/2007
  thumbs down
(Pennacchio)
thumbs up
 
Reno 911!: Miami 02/25/2007
  thumbs up
(Pennacchio)
thumbs down
 
Amazing Grace 02/25/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Music & Lyrics 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Bridge To Terabithia 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Breach 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
Black Snake Moan 02/18/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Smith)
thumbs up
 
The Lives Of Others* (see key) 02/18/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs down
 
Norbit# (see key) 02/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
Factory Girl 02/11/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
The Astronaut Farmer 02/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs down
 
Because I Said So (see key) 02/11/2007
  thumbs down
(Schwarzbaum)
thumbs up
 
The Situation 02/11/2007
 
 
  thumbs down
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Alpha Dog 01/21/2007
  thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs down
 
Arthur And The Invisibles 01/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Seraphim Falls 01/21/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Murty)
thumbs up
 
Catch And Release 01/21/2007
  thumbs down
(Murty)
thumbs down
 
Alone With Her 01/21/2007
 
 
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
The Painted Veil 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Miss Potter 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Notes On A Scandal 01/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs down
 
Perfume: The Story Of A Murderer 01/07/2007
both thumbs up thumbs up
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Pan's Labyrinth 01/07/2007
  thumbs down
(Scott)
thumbs up
 
Curse Of The Golden Flower 01/07/2007

 

bold = best of the year (12/30/2007 Roeper & Scott)

italic = worst of the year (01/13/2008 Roeper & Phillips)

* = best of the year so far (06/10/2007 Roeper & Lemire)

# = worst of the year so far (06/10/2007 Roeper & Lemire)

 

complete listing of Ebert, Siskel, & Roeper's annual top ten lists

this page last modified 02/21/2024
Valid HTML5Valid CSS!
feedback: